The Silence In Between by Josie Ferguson - Review

This was the July choice for my book club and I read it on Kindle. I did mostly enjoy it but had a few caveats that took my star rating down a bit. 

The book has a dual narrative. In the first one, Lisette is around thirty years old and has two children. Ellie is fifteen and Axel is only a few weeks old. Axel is unwell and Lisette takes him to the hospital in West Berlin. She is urged to go home and sleep and come back in the morning with clothes for him and her. But in the morning, the people of East Berlin find that the Wall has gone up overnight and they are no longer permitted to travel there freely. Axel is stuck in the hospital and no one can do anything. But Ellie is determined to smuggle herself in to West Berlin to rescue her baby brother. 

In the second narrative, it is Berlin during World War Two. Lisette lives with her mother who I think was called Rita. Her father is off fighting and Rita waits for him to come home forever more, years after the war has ended. Lisette is in love with a neighbour, Julius, who has been drafted to fight and must leave. The women are friends with a neighbour, Frau Weber, who is a Nazi, althought from Lisette's point of view she and her mother definitely aren't. THEY definitely don't think Jewish people are subhuman or whatever like those NASTY Nazis do! I really didn't like this part of the book because I felt like it exonerated Lisette and her family too much. The book moves on to what happened after the Soviets moved in and how terrible they were to the Germans. The book is pretty harrowing in terms of sexual assault and rape. Others in my book club felt like Lisette was right in what she did, but I'm not sure I agree. 

It was interesting to read about what happened in Berlin during the war, especially from the point of view of women, who are often left behind in war. However, it was often hard to tell the difference between Lisette's and Ellie's points of view, so when the timeline shifted it was hard to tell who it was. Especially when Lisette was a young woman; then the book read more like Young Adult fiction and it just didn't quite ring true for me. I also didn't like how, I felt, no one took responsibility for Nazi actions. 

In all I am giving it three and a half out of five. My caveats mean it got rounded down from four stars.