Pages

Rebecca McCormick. Powered by Blogger.

Hamnet by Maggie O'Farrell - Review

Tuesday, March 11, 2025

I love Maggie O'Farrell, as you probably know, as I've read and reviewed a few of her books over the course of this blog, and I recommend The Vanishing Act of Esme Lennox a lot because I really like it. I follow Maggie's Facebook page so I had heard of this book, but I hadn't ever picked it up. But then it was a book club choice for this year, so when I saw it in a sale in WH Smith I picked it up for a fiver. I was apprehensive because I wasn't sure if it would be a bit too high brow for me. But I picked it up.

And I ended up loving it and I now want everyone I know to read it! I lent it to someone at book club but then I will lend it to my mum because I think she will like it. 

So, if you don't know, Hamnet was the only son of William Shakespeare and Anne Hathaway. I knew that, and I knew he died as a child, of the plague. I also knew that he had a twin, Judith, and an older sister, Susanna. But I didn't know much else about his life. And I had a vague impression that the play Hamlet was called that after him. 

Which, indeed, it was. The book starts by saying that the names Hamnet and Hamlet were interchangeable at the time. Then Hamnet himself is watching Judith as she becomes unwell with what is the bubonic plague. He goes downstairs in the house looking for his mother, his sister, or his grandmother, but can't find any of them. Susanna and his grandmother, Mary, are running errands. His mother is out at Hewlands, her familial home. Hamnet fears his sister will die. 

Lee and I visited Shakespeare's house in Stratford on Avon back in 2020 so it was great that I could envisage the house perfectly. We also went to Anne Hathaway's house but couldn't go in because it was closed due to Covid. But it meant I knew what it looked like. 

So in the book Shakespeare himself is away in London, working and acting and earning his living. The book goes back in time, though, to when he and Anne met. In the book she is called Agnes, because apparently her father's will named her as so. Maggie has really done her research! 

Agnes' mother is portrayed as having been a bit of a witch, a healer, that kind of thing. She died and Agnes' father married Joan, and they had several more children. Agnes and her brother Bartholemew are close in the novel, but she and Joan don't get on. John Shakespeare - William's dad, who he's portrayed as having a volatile relationship with, and who was a glove maker by trade - owed Agnes' dad some money or something and as payment John arranged for William - aged just eighteen - to go tutor some of the younger boys. There he met Agnes, who was older than him and a bit of a wild girl, and who was desperate to leave her stepmother's house. They clearly got married and had Susanna and then the twins. 

The books flips backwards and forwards in time to William and Agnes' relationship and Agnes in particular and how she dealt with her husband and how unhappy he was in Stratford. I don't know how much of this is true but I don't care. It was a good narrative. I also learnt that Hamnet's cause of death is not actually recorded, but it's assumed he did die of the plague. I loved Agnes as a character and I think the book really showed just how difficult life was back then. She didn't have it easy and neither did the rest of the family. 

I think my book club will as a whole have really enjoyed the book but I'm interested for the discussion! I'm giving it five out of five because I loved it. 

Show Me Where It Hurts by Claire Gleeson - Review

Saturday, March 8, 2025


I saw someone on my Instagram reading this book and was really intrigued by the premise. It isn't out yet so I went looking on Netgalley and found it! So I requested it and got it soon after! So thank you very much to Hodder & Stoughton for granting me access to this book. I absolutely raced through it, it's very compelling and I couldn't stop reading. 

I was provided with an electronic copy of this book for review purposes. I was not otherwise compensated for this post and all thoughts and opinions are my own. 

The protagonist of the book is Rachel. She is Irish and is a nurse. She is driving home from visiting her in laws one March day. Her husband Tom is driving; he has been suffering from depression for a while. Their two children, a boy and a girl, are in the back of the car. They are four and almost three. Tom drives the car off the road, intending to kill all four of them. 

The narrative goes backwards and forwards in time, showing Rachel very soon after the 'incident' and then further on in her life when she has managed to put herself back together and forge a new life for herself, even though it looks really different from the life she had planned out. Then it also goes back in time to when Rachel and Tom first met, and their relationship and marriage, having their children, and Tom's illness and how that came about. 

It isn't clear to begin with whether Tom has survived or not, so I don't really want to spoil that. The narrative is told in little vignettes, so it isn't straightfoward prose at all. There were a few times when I really wanted to know more - for instance, there's a part where Rachel gives an interview to someone, and I would really have liked to see the aftermath of that, but no, we then go backwards in time to see what's happening in the past. But for me that's really the sign of a good novel, that I really want to know more. 

I really think this book is going to go viral once it's out. It is going to get everyone talking - what would YOU do? How would you survive? It's the type of book to definitely be picked for a Richard and Judy book club type of thing, and for good reason. It is beautiful about grief and doesn't flinch away from it. It's brutal about living with someone with a severe mental illness (something I have a lot of personal experience with). But it is also so beautiful. Rachel does manage to make a new life for herself but she also has to make new relationships with her family; her parents, who love her but are removed from her, and her sister Rebecca, who has been wayward in the past but who has two children only slightly older than Rachel's. There's stuff in the past about her relationships with her in laws and with Tom, of course. 

The children aren't named in the book which I actually really liked - they're known more by their attributes then than anything else. I thought this was a really effective way of writing a book. I've read that Claire Gleeson is a short story writer primarily and I think that really shows, but I really do hope she writes another novel in the future as I would really like to read something else by her. I'm giving this four out of five. 

The Cottage by Lisa Stone - Review

Thursday, March 6, 2025



For my birthday my friend Leanne sent me this book in a very cute gift box. The book was wrapped, so it was like a 'blind date' book, and in the box was hot chocolate and some self care things, so it was a very cute gift. This was the book inside and I was really intrigued by the premise, so I picked it up in mid February. However, I didn't think it lived up to the premise at all and just got annoyed with it by the end. 

Jan is around thirty years old and she is staying in this isolated cottage. It belongs to Camile, but she's off doing something so she advertised for a lodger and someone to look after her dog, Tinder. Jan lost her boyfriend and her job in the same week so she's decided to take this job to have a bit of a breather and to maybe write. Camile's friend Chris lives close by and keeps dropping in to help Jan. The cottage is on the end of a dense woods and nearish to a village. A village where everyone knows each other. The local shop owner is Chris' sister in law or something. 

Anyway, Jan and Tinder keep getting disturbed every night by someone or something coming into the garden. Jan keeps trying to open the door to see what it is but can't catch proper sight of it. Tinder keeps chasing whatever it is and gets through the hedge and disappears for a couple of hours. Jan is really disturbed, a few nights in a row, but instead of doing the sensible thing and going to stay with a friend, she decides she can't go because Tinder doesn't travel in a car well. I mean fine but I would rather deal with a dog sick in the car that a spooky thing in the garden night after night!

I couldn't decide if this book was going to be supernatural or more basic crime thriller, so that did keep me guessing. But Jan just kept making the most stupid decisions. There's a motion sensor light which Jan turns back on but then Chris and Camile both discourage her from doing it. I guess this is supposed to make you doubt Chris, but it just didn't work for me much. 

And the writing in places is just so stupid. Lisa Stone also writes under the name Cathy Glass, and she's written loads of books, but if they're all as badly written as this I can't understand why she's sold so many. There's so many parts where something is implied... and then it's completely explained as to what the author means. And it's like... let the reader understand your meaning. You don't have to explain it all to me! 

There's a secondary plotline concerning Ian and his wife Emma. Emma is pregnant and gives birth at home in the presence of a midwife called Anne. Baby David is born stillborn, so Anne takes the body away. But a neighbour becomes concerned about the baby and phones the police. The police are mildly involved which I thought would go further... but no. The two plotlines do intersect but in such a ridiculous way. Plus I felt the middle was just too long. The tensions keeps ramping up and so on and so on, but then it just went on and on and I needed there to be a resolution. 

I can't give this any more than two out of five. It's just not good. 

My Heart is Hurting by S E Reed - Blog Tour and Review

Monday, March 3, 2025


Hello and welcome to my turn on the blog tour for My Heart Is Hurting by S E Reed. It is a pleasure to welcome you here. Please do have a click around and read some of my other reviews. I read a lot of Young Adult so when I saw this book I signed up for the tour. 

This book was one of the entries for BBNYA which is a competition where indie authors can get their novels read and judged. I was a reader a few years ago but didn't have time to sign up for the full thing, but I was happy to get to read this one. 

Here's the blurb and author bio:

Blurb


Jinny Buffett is lonely…


She’s never had the comfort of a white picket fence with a loving family. Her subsidized apartment in Hollywood Florida echoes with the void of her dead Daddy, and the nights drag long into twilight while her Mama works the block outside the Margaritaville resort.


It’s idealistic Ms. Fleming, who’s brave enough to come knocking first. She wants to see Jinny rise up and use her ace scores to escape the wheel of poverty, convincing Jinny to start a school book club, where she finds the friends and boyfriend she never knew she needed.


But when her Mama spirals out of control and threatens her entire existence, it’s Jinny’s Everglade ancestors who arrive in a mist of magic, bringing the swamp and hope with them.



Author Bio


S.E. Reed lives in the south and writes strange, haunting, real stories of people and places along old highways.


Winner of the 2024 Florida Book Awards and the 2024 Paterson Prize for Books for Young People.


Additionally, she's been nominated for a Pushcart Prize and won honorable mention twice in L. Ron Hubbard's Writers of the Future Contest.


You can find her on X @writingwithreed or visit her website www.writingwithreed.com .



I really liked Jinny and loved her story. She's incredibly lonely. Her mother is neglectful and disappears for weeks at a time. Jinny doesn't trust people easily, so she doesn't trust Ms Fleming. There's a new boy at school, though. Tom. He's just moved and he and Jinny become close. Plus two friends from a while ago reappear and Jinny eventually lets them in. She realises everyone has problems. 

There is some magic with regards to Jinny's dad's family, but I wish it had been a bit more overt and that there was more of it. I also want to say that using the word 'said' is absolutely fine. There were so many synonyms that it was really jarring. That's my critcism really. But generally I liked Jinny and wanted her to succeed. 

Think Again by Jacqueline Wilson - Review

Friday, February 28, 2025


My friend Helen sent me this book, which was really nice of her, thinking I would like it. Well, wanting me to read it, at least. Like many others my age I read some Jacqueline Wilson when I was young, but I hadn't ever read the Girls series, on which this is based. So I didn't have the frame of reference for this, and maybe it would have helped if I had? I ended up just not really liking this and finding it really weird. I said as much to Helen and she agreed that it was odd, so I'm glad it wasn't just me!

So, the protagonist of the book is Ellie. She is turning forty at the beginning of the book. She wants to spend the day with her beloved daughter, Lottie, who has just started university, but Lottie cancels on her at the last minute. So Ellie goes swimming and she meets Alice. Ellie is the artist of a comic strip that appears in the Guardian - a mouse called Myrtle - which it turns out to have been cancelled by the paper just before Ellie's birthday and Alice knows of it. She ends up dragging Ellie to get the mouse tattooed. Now I am a person with a lot of tattoos and I thought the description of Ellie getting the tattoo was spot on, but I thought the depiction of the aftercare was absolutely terrible! Ellie first of all has a bandage on it, and then she goes swimming about a week later! It's not hard to do your research!

Anyway, Ellie ends up being thrown a surprise party. There's her dad, her stepmum Anna, her brother Ben, her brother in law Simon, Lottie, and her two best friends Nadine and Magda. Then there's a bunch of other people from her life including an old PE teacher Mrs Henderson, a woman who once encouraged her drawing career, and I dunno, a bunch of others. It got confusing. She gets back in touch with her old art teacher, Gary because of this party. 

Ellie, having lost the comic gig, decides to write a graphic novel about elephants. Alice can help her with this, because she has researched elephants a lot. But her girlfriend Wendy doesn't like Ellie at all, which isn't really investigated properly. Ellie then starts a relationship with her old teacher, Gary, which is very weird and creepy and not at all fine! They have really good sex but otherwise he's a bit boorish and annoying. He lectures her. He doesn't like the flat she lives in. She says she 'can't' break up with him but it's like -- why not? You don't owe him anything! Just break it off! She spends literally half the book fannying about with this. 

Then there's Magda and Nadine. Nadine is her 'old self', still falling in and out of bed with loads of men. Magda is pregnant but the baby's dad is Chris, who Ellie and Nadine don't like. They don't like his kids either. But there's no reason given why they dislike him so much. It's very surface.

In fact the whole thing is surface. And as a woman who turned forty in the same year that this was published I did have to think that no, we're not all as vacuous and self involved as Ellie. She had had some genuine trauma in her life but that too was skated over. 

In all I'm giving this two out of five and not a scrap more. 

While We're Young by K L Walther - Review and Blog Tour

Tuesday, February 25, 2025


Hello and welcome to my blog for my turn on the tour for While We're Young by K L Walther! I am so happy to welcome you here. Please do click around and have a read of some of my other reviews! 

When I read the premise of this book I was really intrigued by it so signed up for the tour. I was lucky enough to receive a paper copy of the book which I've really enjoyed reading and which I will probably keep. This is a really good book and deserves to go viral and have some buzz around it when it's published because it's the cutest type of Young Adult novel. The premise also promised that it's kind of a modern update to the film Ferris Bueller's Day Off which is one of my favourite films, so I was really intrigued to read this! As I type, I am about 80% of the way through so I don't know how the book will end, but I am enjoying it so far and am excited to see what happens at the end. 

There are four protagonists in the book so it is quite complex as they all have a lot going on. They are all seniors in high school. Grace is class president and she's pretty preppy and a good girl .That's why when she fakes illness to skip school one day in her last May of high school, neither of her parents really bats an eyelid. They both have important meetings so they're busy anyway, so they're happy to leave Grace at home. Grace then persuades her best friend Isa to skip school too. She wants to go on a road trip with her. They get Isa out of school and then they turn their attention to Everett. They basically kidnap him from school and the three of them set off to Philadelphia. 

Isa is very popular and very clever and she's headed to Brown University. However her parents really want her to go to Harvard, Yale, or Princeton, so they're actually a bit disappointed. Everett is the eldest of three siblings and his dad has died recently, so the whole family is struggling to learn to deal with his loss. Isa and Everett used to go out, but when they broke up they stopped being friends too, putting Grace in the middle. Part of her plan for the day is to get Isa and Everett back to being friends, basically because she misses that but also because she and Everett kind of have feelings for each other and she doesn't want to go behind Isa's back. 

Then there's James. James and Grace are siblings and are in the same year at school as there's only about ten months between them. In the past they were very close, but a few things have got between them and now they just wind each other up. James and Isa have kind of started a relationship but they know this won't go down well with Grace so they've cooled off a bit until Grace knows. James is a bit of a troublemaker at school and starts his day with a meeting with the principal. She is less than impressed with him but James does start his day. But then he realises that Grace, Isa, and Everett are all missing from school, so he skips out and goes home, and obviously finds Grace isn't there. 

Because she's in Philadelphia, trying to have a fun day like they all used to go on with Everett's dad. But of course there are so many obstacles in the way... 

I loved all four teens and the very real and many problems that they are dealing with. I won't give spoilers for these but there's lots, but they all felt very realistic. I liked all four of their personalities too, but I especially liked Grace. I had sympathy for all of them. I also loved all the nods to Ferris Bueller's Day Off - like Grace and Isa take one of Isa's parents' cars, and there's a bit where someone appears on the TV, and the local news reporters are called Ferris and Cameron. The school goes wild over the idea that Grace is ill and there's a hashtag very quickly - #SavingGrace. I would recommend seeing the film if you haven't because there were so many little nods which felt like the author paying tribute to a film.

As I said, I haven't quite finished the book but I've really enjoyed it so far and am giving it four out of five. I would definitely read something else by the same author, too! 

The Crow Trap by Ann Cleeves - Review

Friday, February 21, 2025



My mum said to me last year that she had never read any of Ann Cleeves' books and I thought she would like the Vera series so for Christmas I bought her the first eight books I think, in a lovely set in a cardboard holder. I think it was around £25 off eBay, brand new, which makes it excellent value per book. She read the first book and lent it to me. I've read a few of the Vera books but out of order, so it was weird to go back to the beginning. Especially as the book was printed in 1999 so it's weird how much technology there wasn't around. 

My mum's criticism is that Vera didn't appear until way late on in the book, which she didn't like. She has also never seen the TV show so in one way that helped, because she had no pre conceived notions about Vera here, whereas I definitely always see her as Brenda Blethyn! I'm sad the TV show has finished actually because I've watched it religiously, but I did enjoy the documentary about it and would recommend it for fans. 

Anyway, this book. Three women are arriving at Baikie's Cottage to carry out an environmental study on the area. This is because a local company wants to build a quarry nearby (do you build a quarry??) and these three geologists need to make sure that there's nothing special that would be destroyed. Baikie's Cottage is near to Black Law Farm, where Bella and Douglas live. Douglas has had a stroke and needs a lot of care; Bella is his second wife and dedicated to him. However, at the beginning of the book, when one of the women, Rachael, arrives, she finds Bella dead in the barn.

She and Bella have been close and she is shocked by the apparent suicide. She doesn't believe it, but everyone else seems to. Rachael is reeling from the betrayal of her boss and ex lover, Peter, so she wants to lie low for a bit. She has an eccentric mother, Edie, and she wants to know about her dad, who Edie refuses to tell her about. 

The second woman, Anne, is local to the area but choosing to sleep at the cottage. She is pretty unhappily married to a man called Jeremy, but is also having an affair with a man who has something to do with the new quarry. I don't know, I lost the plot entirely because there were far too many characters and it was hard to keep them straight in my head. I liked her best of the three women I think. 

The third woman is Grace. She's a lot younger than the others and somewhat of a loner. She shares the same surname as the local toffs of the manor up at the big house, but it's not clear at first how she's related, if she is at all. I found her story just quite sad to be honest. 

As I said, there's a ton of characters and then there's another dead body, and it's just very confusing and unclear about who is who and what they've got to do with anything. For that reason I can only give it three out of five. I did like meeting Vera so I will definitely read the rest when my mum passes them on, but I just found this overly long and confusing. There were bits of plot that just went nowhere, and too many coincidences for my liking. I think Ann has got better at these books along the way! 
 

Blogger news

Blogroll

Most Read

Tags